The English poet John Keats expressed the idea of negative capability in a letter to his brother In 1817. He described it as the capacity for accepting uncertainty and the possibility that certain questions might never be resolved. The great writers, according to Keats, are those with the greatest negative capability. He credited Shakespeare with the greatest talent in this regard, and thought that the dynamic tension created by perpetual uncertainty made for the most interesting characters and depth in story.
I came across this term while watching a baseball documentary called “The Tenth Inning”that addressed the steroid scandal from a few years ago. In the documentary, sportswriter George Wil says “Now we live in a sports age and a baseball age, where nothing’s more valuable than negative capability because if we’re just in a rush, if we can’t wait to see Roger Clemens or Barry Bonds, or whoever it is, as right or wrong, then we’re missing the complexity of these people and the difficulty of the age that they’re living in.”
What does this have to do with the Catholic faith or anything to do with this blog?
Well, we are in a scandal of our own locally. I much darker and serious issue than baseball and steroids. Living through it can be a full time chore and the idea of negative capability intrigues me. I have to admit my cycles of anger, frustration, despair and a few “What were they thinking!” moments as I read, along with everyone else, the accounts reported by certain radio stations and other media outlets. Working for the church does not make me immune to or “in the know” on anything, in fact, working for the church seems to make every news report of a fallen priest or a seemingly poor decision feel like a personal affront to my faith and work.
So how do you hang onto your faith when your church is in crisis?
I have been trying to tap into that Negative Capability. It is a strange name and since I am not a literary intellect, I’ve never read Keats or studied Shakespeare and I am surprised at how I am drawn to this odd literary term. But it seems to describe a way I aproach my faith life. In my early stages of (re)conversion to the Church, I hungered for knowledge and devoured books. Knowledge of the one I loved, the one I sought – so much like Song of Songs.
On my bed night after night I sought him
But in wanting to know God – in wanting to know Christ, I wanted to understand and figure out the complexities and abserdities of a virgin giving birth, the irrational math of the trinity and duality of transubstantiation. In my desire for knowledge, I couldn’t rest in faith. I wanted proof. I wanted answers. In my struggles I could only hope for Divine Grace to step in. I needed to learn to rest in that negative capability and enjoy the tension of this amazing church that isn’t about either/or – but lives in the and/also of a faith based on a Man who is also the Son of God who really is present in the Mass.
Crisis of Faith
In regards to our current clergy abuse crisis, I have also had to yield to this negative capability in a darker way. I have to rest in questions that may never be resolved. I have been sickened by the reports. The victims are tragic and the deeds and actions of a few priest are abominable. It is very easy to paint a black and white picture of the people involved, but the personalities are as complex as are the times in which they live. We are called to see everyone through the eye that God sees us. Through the fullness of who they are.
In all of this we are called to pray for the victims, but also the perpetrators. We are called to love our good priests and also the fallen. We must love the whistel blowers, the reporters, and the angry Catholics who have left the church. Only in this strange church filled with the hard teaching are we called to forgive and love and carry on. (all while protecting the inocent and sin no more)
Only in this lovely faith called the Catholic Church could we celebrate the Friday that Christ was crucified and call it Good.