The Magi versus the Chief Priests and the Scribes
The visit of the magi to Jesus in Bethlehem reveals a deeply disturbing fact: the chief priests and the scribes did not go to visit Jesus like the magi. In fact, they conspired with King Herod who wanted to destroy the child. The chief priests and the scribes were quite unlike the magi, and they are a remarkable study in contrast.
The magi were pagans, Gentiles, non-believers; from Persia, a foreign country to the east; scholars and experts on secular subjects such as medicine, philosophy, and astronomy; belonged to an upper priestly caste; practiced as fortune tellers and magicians; and were ridiculed by ordinary Jews as superstitious, misinformed, and misguided.
On the other hand, the chief priests and scribes were Jews, members of God’s Chosen People; from Israel, the Promised Land; scholars and experts on spiritual subjects such as Scripture, the Law, and the prophets; served as the priests and elders of the Temple; despised fortune telling and magic; and were widely respected by ordinary Jews as holy, devout, and well-informed.
The reaction and response of the magi to the birth of Jesus is shockingly different from the chief priests and the scribes. When the star appeared in the night sky, the magi noticed the star, were excited about the star, made a clear decision to seek the newborn king of the Jews, followed the star, traveled hundreds of miles, spent weeks or months on the journey, used a portion of their life’s savings to make the trip, brought expensive gifts, consulted with others for additional guidance, and once they found Jesus, they were filled with joy, prostrated themselves before him, paid him homage, and offered him expensive gifts.
On the other hand, the chief priests and the scribes failed to notice the star. When they learned about the birth of the newborn king of the Jews, they were not excited, they had no desire to go and see the child, they were unwilling to travel five or six miles or to set aside part of a day to make the trip to nearby Bethlehem, spent none of their resources on traveling or gifts, failed to take heed of their own Scriptures regarding the birth of the Messiah, were flat and unaffected, gave Jesus no honor or worship, and presented him with no gifts.
This is a supreme irony. A positive response to Jesus should have been forthcoming from the religious leaders of Israel, not from pagans from a faraway country. The outsiders responded and believed. The insiders were complacent and resisted.
Not only is this contrast shocking, and the response of the chief priests and scribes disappointing, even appalling, it should serve as a warning to us. Practicing Catholics and regular church-goers would classify themselves as “religious” or “devout.” This is the same way that the chief priests and scribes described themselves. Even though they had the advantage of a religious upbringing, knew Scripture, and worshiped regularly, they did not respond to Jesus. We must avoid their pitfall. It is important for us to watch for Jesus, pursue him with all our hearts, expend whatever time and energy is needed to go to him, examine the Scriptures for guidance, prostrate ourselves in praise and worship before him, and offer him our finest gifts.